In case it wasn't clear from my previous message, not even having the option to see all replies at once is a major downside of the Redesign, in my view.

I agree with @gpillsbury and would vote for expansion vs. sidebar. Another big advantage of going with the expansion approach is that you could (hopefully) have a Collapse/Expand All Replies optio...

Just adding that I, too, think it's important to have an option to expand all replies. 

I agree, there's no solution here...so why is this marked as "solved"?

This was fantastic, thanks!

Just adding that I, too, think it's important to have an option to expand all replies. 

In case it wasn't clear from my previous message, not even having the option to see all replies at once is a major downside of the Redesign, in my view.

I agree with @gpillsbury and would vote for expansion vs. sidebar. Another big advantage of going with the expansion approach is that you could (hopefully) have a Collapse/Expand All Replies optio...

I agree, there's no solution here...so why is this marked as "solved"?

This was fantastic, thanks!